Best Car Seat Buyer’s Guide: Best Car Seat for a Tall Toddler

child sleeping in the car seat

When you first bought your car seat for your baby, you probably didn’t expect your little peanut to get so tall so quickly. Not all car seats can comfortably fit tall toddlers. For both your child’s safety and comfort, you will need to get a car seat with a higher height limit that can accommodate his or her tall height. This guide will list 10 car seats with tall height maximums and other comfort features. You will be well on your way to finding the best car seat for tall toddler or preschool-age children.

Comparison Table

Product FAQs

Why Should You Buy a Car Seat for Your Tall Toddler?

How Do You Choose a Car Seat for Your Tall Toddler?

Where Can You Buy a Car Seat?

How We Determined Our Ratings

We thoroughly researched all the car seats in this guide and rated them for how well they can accommodate a tall toddler. We also considered their safety, durability, convenience, comfort level and price.

Overall Price Range 

On average, car seats average from $$$ to $$$. You can find some car seats for under $$$ while others can reach as high as $$$.

toddler sleeping on the

Image via Pixabay

- ​Top 10 Best Car Seats for Tall Toddlers -

Graco 4Ever 4-in-1 Convertible Car Seat

No products found.

People love this convertible car seat by Graco because they only need to buy one car seat or booster for their child until he or she is ready to sit in a car without one. You’ll be happy to know that even your tall toddler will be able to ride in this car seat rear-facing since it can accommodate children up to 49 inches tall in both the rear-facing and front-facing positions. The headrest and harness system makes it super easy to adjust the height between 10 different height options.

PROS

  • Easy to adjust to child’s height
  • High rear-facing height limit

CONS

  • Uses LATCH system, which isn’t ideal for larger children
  • Rear-facing weight limit is only 40 pounds

Britax Boulevard ClickTight Convertible Car Seat

Sale
Britax Boulevard ClickTight Convertible Car Seat, Circa
  • Easy installation: Patented ClickTight makes car seat installation as simple as buckling a seat belt
  • No rethreading, ever: Quick-adjust 14-position harness with Click & Safe Snug Indicator gives a click sound when the...
  • Adjust accurately: Harness indicator gives an audible click when you've pulled to the proper tightness

Like the Graco 4Ever 4-in-1, the Britax Boulevard is great for tall rear-facing toddlers since it can fit children as tall as 49 inches both rear-facing and front-facing. You can adjust the height of the harness with just the push of a button and choose between 14 different positions until you find the perfect fit. This car seat also has some great safety features like two layers of side impact protection and a Click & Safe Snug Indicator, which will click to let you know when the harness is tight enough.  

PROS

  • 14 different harness positions
  • Audible click when harness is tight
  • ClickTight installation technology
  • High rear-facing weight limit

CONS

  • Expensive option
  • Rear-facing weight limit is only 40 pounds

Evenflo Symphony DLX All-In-One Convertible Car Seat

No products found.

The Evenflo Symphony is another great option for a car seat that will grow with your child until he or she is much older. It can accommodate rear-facing toddlers up to 40 inches tall and front-facing toddlers up to 50 inches. The harness and recline positions are super easy to adjust, too. Evenflo is the industry leader in safety and rollover standards, meaning you can be certain of your toddler's protection in case of a crash.

PROS

  • Affordable convertible option
  • Decent front-facing height limit
  • Easy to adjust

CONS

  • Height and weight limits are not ideal for extended rear-facing

Maxi-Cosi Pria 85 Max Convertible Car Seat

Sale
Maxi,Cosi Maxi,Cosi Pria 85 Max Convertible Car Seat, Night Black,...
  • Extended weight range keeps children safely harnessed longer: 5-40 pounds rear facing and 22-85 pounds forward-facing
  • The only harnessed convertible car seat rated to 85 pounds (as of November 2016)
  • ClipQuik auto-magnetic chest clip gets you on your way quickly

The Maxi-Cosi Pria is a very comfortable, stylish choice for your tall toddler, and it has cool safety features like the patented Air Protect cushioning system. The height limit for rear-facing toddlers in this car seat is pretty standard at 40 inches, but it can fit front-facing toddlers up to 52 inches, which is several inches taller than most car seats. Also, this car seat can accommodate heavier toddlers with a weight limit of 85 pounds.

PROS

  • High front-facing height limit
  • Weight limit of 85 pounds
  • Extremely comfortable and safe

CONS

  • Height and weight limits are not ideal for extended rear-facing
  • Very expensive option 

Graco Extend2Fit Convertible Car Seat

No products found.

This adjustable car seat is great for keeping your tall toddler rear-facing as long as possible with its rear-facing and front-facing height limit of 49 inches. It can also accommodate rear-facing toddlers up to 50 pounds. One great feature of this car seat is that there is an extension panel on the front of the car seat that provides up to 5 inches of additional legroom, so your tall toddler will be very comfortable.

PROS

  • High rear-facing height and weight limit
  • Adjustable leg room
  • Easy to adjust between 10 different height positions
  • Very affordable option

CONS

  • Does not convert into a booster seat
  • Uses the LATCH system

Diono Radian R120 All-in-One Convertible Car Seat

No products found.

This compact car seat won’t take up too much space in your car, but it will easily fit even the tallest of toddlers. You can have your toddler rear-facing as long as possible with a height limit of 44 inches. Once your child is front-facing, he or she will fit in this car seat until a height of 57 inches or a weight of 65 pounds. This car seat is very heavy but durable with its EPS foam insulation and its aluminum reinforced sides.

PROS

  • High front-facing height limit of 57 inches
  • Very narrow, making it a great choice for compact cars
  • Uses the SuperLATCH installation system, which is thought to be safer than the regular LATCH system
  • Accommodates children up to 120 pounds

CONS

  • The Diono Rainier is a better option by the same brand for only $10 more

Combi Compact Car Seat

Combi Compact Convertible Car Seat Rear and Forward Facing for Baby...
  • TRU-SAFE: Combi utilizes Tru-Safe Side Impact Protection in its Convertible Car Seat. This offers deep side walls and a...
  • COMPACT, LIGHTWEIGHT AND THREE ACROSS: The Coccoro Convertible Car Seat was designed with small spaces in mind. At 15.5...
  • COMFORTABLE AND EASE OF USE: The Coccoro Convertible Car Seat has a buckle with an indicator that provides a visual cue...

Although finding a car seat that can fit your tall toddler can be hard, this car seat makes life simple with its convenient installation and adjusting features. This car seat has a SuperCinch Latch Tightener to secure the car seat easily. It is plenty tall enough for your rear-facing toddler with a height limit of 49 inches. The front-facing limit is also 49 inches, which is average for most car seats.

PROS

  • High rear-facing height limit of 49 inches
  • Very easy to adjust
  • Nine position and recline options
  • Plenty of visual indicators to help you install your car seat correctly

CONS

  • Expensive option
  • Does not turn into a booster

Evenflo SureRide DLX

Evenflo SureRide DLX Convertible Car Seat, Carson
  • 2 Seats in 1: Two Modes of Harness use - Rear-Facing and Forward-Facing
  • e3 Expanded Zone of Protection: 3 layers of energy-absorbing foam provide superior protection and reduces side impact...
  • Up-Front Harness Adjust: Central, front access to harness adjuster provides an easy way to adjust child's harness for an...

If you are looking for a budget option that is both comfortable and safe for your toddler, the SureRide by Evenflo is a great choice. The rear-facing height limit for this car seat is pretty average at 40 inches, but it can accommodate front-facing toddlers as tall as 54 inches.  

PROS

  • Very affordable option
  • High front-facing height limit of 54 inches

CONS

  • Basic car seat that will be hard to adjust
  • Only has a rear-facing height limit of 40 inches

Diono Rainier

No products found.

Like the Diono Radian, this car seat is able to accommodate even the tallest toddlers with a rear-facing height limit of 44 inches and a front-facing height limit of 57 inches. The Diono Rainier can support more weight in both the rear-facing and front-facing positions, and there is an extra aluminum reinforced headrest that can is adjustable between 12 different positions.  

PROS

  • Great front-facing height limit of 57 inches
  • Easy to adjust
  • Narrow car seat

CONS

  • Very heavy car seat

Combi Compact Convertible Car Seat Rear

Combi Compact Convertible Car Seat Rear and Forward Facing for Baby...
  • TRU-SAFE: Combi utilizes Tru-Safe Side Impact Protection in its Convertible Car Seat. This offers deep side walls and a...
  • COMPACT, LIGHTWEIGHT AND THREE ACROSS: The Coccoro Convertible Car Seat was designed with small spaces in mind. At 15.5...
  • COMFORTABLE AND EASE OF USE: The Coccoro Convertible Car Seat has a buckle with an indicator that provides a visual cue...

This car seat is another budget option that can accommodate your tall toddler. It can fit rear-facing toddlers up to 40 inches tall and front-facing toddlers up to 52 inches. It is a compact car seat that doesn’t take up a lot of space in your car. You can fit three of these car seats side by side.  

PROS

  • Can accommodate toddlers up to 52 inches tall in front-facing position
  • Extremely affordable

CONS

  • Hard to adjust the harness
  • Height and weight limits on this car seat is not ideal for extended rear-facing
  • Uses LATCH system

Model: Graco 4Ever 4-in-1 Convertible Car Seat

Car Seat Dimensions: 21.5 x 20 x 24 inches

Car Seat Weight: 22.75 pounds

Positions: Front-facing, rear-facing, booster, backless booster

Weight Limit: 4 pounds to 120 pounds

Rear-Facing Max Height: 49 inches

Front-Facing Max Height: 49 inches

Warranty: One year

Purchase: Amazon.com

Our Rating: 4.3/5 Stars

Model: Britax Boulevard ClickTight Convertible Car Seat

Car Seat Dimensions: 23 x 18.5 x 23.5 inches

Car Seat Weight: 29.4 pounds

Positions: Front and rear facing

Weight Limit: 5 pounds to 65 pounds

Rear-Facing Max Height: 49 inches

Front-Facing Max Height: 49 inches

Warranty: One year

Purchase: Amazon.com

Our Rating: 4.1/5 Stars

Model: Evenflo Symphony DLX All-In-One Convertible Car Seat

Car Seat Dimensions: 27 x 21 x 19.8 inches

Car Seat Weight: 21 pounds

Positions: Front-facing, rear-facing, booster

Weight Limit: 5 pounds to 110 pounds

Rear-Facing Max Height: 40 inches

Front-Facing Max Height: 50 inches

Warranty: 90 days

Purchase: Amazon.com

Our Rating: 4/5 Stars

Model: Maxi-Cosi Pria 85 Max Convertible Car Seat

Car Seat Dimensions: 18.5 x 20.75 x 29.63 inches

Car Seat Weight: 23.75 pounds

Positions: Rear and front-facing

Weight Limit: 5 pounds to 85 pounds

Rear-Facing Max Height: 40 inches

Front-Facing Max Height: 52 inches

Warranty: Lifetime

Purchase: Amazon.com

Our Rating: 4.1/5 Stars

Model: Graco Extend2Fit Convertible Car Seat

Car Seat Dimensions: 22.1 x 19.2 x 25.2 inches

Car Seat Weight: 23.2 pounds

Positions: Front and rear-facing

Weight Limit: 5 pounds to 65 pounds

Rear-Facing Max Height: 49 inches

Front-Facing Max Height: 49 inches

Warranty: One year

Purchase: Amazon.com

Our Rating: 4.2/5 Stars

Model: Diono Radian R120 All-in-One Convertible Car Seat

Car Seat Dimensions: 16 x 17 x 28.5 inches

Car Seat Weight: 26.4 pounds

Positions: Front-facing, rear-facing, booster

Weight Limit: 5 pounds to 120 pounds

Rear-Facing Max Height: 44 inches

Front-Facing Max Height: 57 inches

Warranty: One year

Purchase: Amazon.com

Our Rating: 4.4/5 Stars

Model: Chicco NextFit Convertible Car Seat

Car Seat Dimensions: 20.5 x 19 x 26 inches

Car Seat Weight: 25.1 pounds

Positions: Front and rear-facing

Weight Limit: 5 pounds to 65 pounds

Rear-Facing Max Height: 49 inches

Front-Facing Max Height: 49 inches

Warranty: One year

Purchase: Amazon.com

Our Rating: 4.2/5 Stars

Model: Evenflo SureRide DLX

Car Seat Dimensions: 29 x 20 x 20 inches

Car Seat Weight: 15. 5 pounds

Positions: Front and rear-facing

Weight Limit: 5 pounds to 65 pounds

Rear-Facing Max Height: 40 inches

Front-Facing Max Height: 54 inches

Warranty: 90 days

Purchase: Amazon.com

Our Rating: 3.7/5 Stars

Model: Diono Rainier

Car Seat Dimensions: 16 x 18 x 28.5 inches

Car Seat Weight: 29.79 pounds

Positions: Front-facing, rear-facing, booster

Weight Limit: 5 pounds to 120 pounds

Rear-Facing Max Height: 44 inches

Front-Facing Max Height: 57 inches

Warranty: One year

Purchase: Amazon.com

Our Rating: 4.5/5 Stars

Model: Eddie Bauer XRS 65

Car Seat Dimensions: 21 x 18.63 x 23.75 inches

Car Seat Weight: 14.37 pounds

Positions: Front and rear-facing

Weight Limit: 5 pounds to 65 pounds

Rear-Facing Max Height: 40 inches

Front-Facing Max Height: 52 inches

Warranty: One year

Purchase: Amazon.com

Our Rating: 3.8/5 Stars

The Final Verdict

The absolute best car seat for tall toddlers is hands down the Diono Rainier. The Diono Rainier can accommodate toddlers as tall as 57 inches and as heavy as 90 pounds before needing to be switched to a booster seat.

Featured Image via Pixabay

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here